WordPress Theme Updates Are New Themes

I know that there are different ways that people approach building WordPress themes and I’m not one to argue that there’s a single right way to do it. Sure, some ways are better than others, but that’s true of a lot of things.

Personally, I approach building themes, plugins, and so on as I would as if I was building some type of software. That has to do with my background. Similarly, someone who has a background in design and in front-end development will conceptualize what they are building in a different way.

Like I said, all of that’s fine (in fact, I think it’d be interested to see how different people view building themes, but I digress), but I do know that one common thing we always have to think about as it relates to updated our WordPress themes is the actual front-end design.

Specifically, does it make sense to completely change the design of a theme for a different version of the theme?

WordPress Theme Updates

Generally speaking, themes should be for presentation, plugins should be for functionality. Yes, there’s a little bit of bleed over (and that’s really the topic for another post), but the short of it is that themes provide the look and feel for a site

For those who purchase themes – regardless of if its for their blog, business website, personal landing page, and so on – the process may generally go through something like this:

  • Have an idea, maybe even a few sketches, for how the page(s) should look
  • Visit a number of theme shops and marketplaces to find a theme
  • Narrow them down to a set of n-favorite themes
  • Select one that meets all of the criteria and looks good
  • Purchase
  • Set it up and start using it

No, not everyone goes looking for themes the same way, but for the average buyer do not underestimate the role that the look and feel of the theme plays in making a decision.

After all, the look and feel is the theme. It’s not the code, the comments, the architecture, none of that. It’s often just how good it looks.

Now, let’s say you’re a theme developer and you’re someone who is working on a theme or a set of themes and you’re looking to begin to plan for the next major version of your theme – for some, this may be a major version bump like 2.0; for others, no so much.

WordPress Theme Updates

It all depends on how you version your work and, in this post, that doesn’t matter. Simply put, redesigns of projects tend to happen during major version releases (whatever your version scheme may be).

So let’s say you’ve got a theme called Acme and you’ve had pretty good success with it regardless of the type of theme that it is and you’re preparing to do a redesign for the next major release.

Personally, I don’t think that’s a good move – not when it comes to themes.

If themes are meant to provide the presentation of a site, and you redesign the way a theme looks, then you’re changing the presentation of the site.

In other words, the theme is no longer the theme that was originally purchased.

Instead, you’ve got a different looking theme that has the same name as a previous theme. To customers, that’s a big difference.

So when others ask if me – or if I’m pulled in a direction of wanting to implement a redesign – if I think that a redesign of a given theme makes sense, I tend to say no. A theme redesign kills the original theme.

Instead, what I’d rather see happen is the original theme continue to be support and maintained with upgrades to fit with new versions of WordPress and/or whatever new additions browsers eventually have, and then to see new themes created from said design.

If your initial theme becomes dated, that’s okay. Only offer support for, say, a year and then retire it. There’s no reason you can’t support an existing theme for the customers, nor is there a reason why you can’t offer them a discount on a new version of a theme.

Whatever we opt to do from a business standpoint is exactly that – our business – but when it comes to actually redesigning themes calling them Acme 2.0, we need to stop.

To the users, it’s not the case. Instead, we’re essentially giving them a different theme with the same name.

3 Replies to “WordPress Theme Updates Are New Themes”

  1. I agree, though it can be a fine line at times. One of our themes has received quite a few updates, many of which were minor updates fixing bugs and making small improvements. But there have also been a couple updates that were more focused on adding something a little new. A new homepage template, a more polished author template, etc. I feel like this kind of update is reasonable, since it’s not really changing anything about the look and feel; it’s just rounding it out.

    The other factor to consider is how this will play for your customers (assuming it’s a commercial theme). If you discontinue the theme they’re using and release a new theme that looks very similar, how will that look to customers? We’re facing this conundrum with one of our themes right now, and it’s definitely a tricky issue to sort out.

  2. “If themes are meant to provide the presentation of a site, and you redesign the way a theme looks, then you’re changing the presentation of the site. In other words, the theme is no longer the theme that was originally purchased.”

    Exactly. But how often does this happen? I see a lot of themes that have subtle variations in layout but are obviously based on the same theme. The developer has made a conscious decision to take a base theme and vary it and offer those discrete variations as different products. That’s the right way to do it.

    Seems like a very bad marketing move to change a theme in any obvious sense, save for backend functionality, addition of widgets, bug fixes, exploiting new WP features, etc. For customers, buying a theme is a very visceral, emotional decision based initially upon the look and feel. Change that, and yes, you have a new theme.

    That said, something has occurred to me. There are two types of theme, broadly speaking: themes that do functionality well, and those that do presentation well. Sometimes they are combined in the same thing, but it’s a difference I see all the time. I think that’s good: not all themes need to have a lot of additional functionality, or any at all. Sometimes you just want a different look on top of the standard WP backend and options.

  3. I never actually looked at theme updates like this before, but I couldn’t agree with you more. When you think about it, some of the larger theme shops, like Studiopress do it this way. They are going through all of their old themes and redoing them – making them mobile responsive, adding html5 syntax, etc… Then appending “Pro” to the theme and retiring the old version.

    How do you feel about plugins with major updates? I was recently working with a “heads up bar” plugin that recently updated to a new version where it completely changed the UI and the look and feel of the final result, which made me find a new solution. It was frustrating.

    Cheers!

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.